Office of the Mental Health Advocate

A Victory for Competency

Jo-Carol Nesset Sale speaking about the Sims case at a recent OMHA public defender training

Congratulations to Jo-Carol Nesset Sale, and the other team of lawyers that assisted in the victory of
the Sims case. The Georgia Supreme Court decided in Sims v. State that the " 'any evidence' standard
of review thwarts genuine review of an appeal from a verdict of competency because the presumption
of competency would always provide some evidence in support of a finding of competency."

Instead, Georgia appellate courts will now review decisions regarding competency under the following
standard, "whether after reviewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the State, a rational trier of
fact could have found that the defendant failed to prove by a preponderance of the evidence that he
was incompetent to stand trial."

The Court reviewed the facts of the case on its own (including that Sims has an IQ of 45 and functions
at the mental age of a seven-year-old) and reversed the trial court's finding that Willie Sims was
competent to stand trial.

This is a wonderful victory and the product of a lot of hard work on the part of Sims' lawyers.

For more information go to www.gasupreme.us case# SO4G1689 decided June 6, 2005.

Announcements and Articles
Friday, January 29, 2010 10:54 AM

Check here frequently for OMHA news and articles about mental health issues in the criminal justice system.

NEW FACE IN THE OFFICE OF THE MENTAL HEALTH ADVOCATE

Deborah R Baldwin, Attorney

The Office of the Mental Health Advocate welcomes its’ 2008 Spring volunteer, Ms. Deborah Baldwin as she starts an internship.
Ms. Baldwin comes to OMHA with a great deal of experience, as well as a passion for upholding the rights of the mentally ill. She has worked in the legal profession since 1988. Having trained as a legal executive, she qualified as an attorney in England in July 1996 and her background has been primarily in criminal and mental health law. She obtained an LLM in Medical Law from the University of Northumbria in 2005.

click here to continue reading >>>

Legislative Update - Changes in 17-7-130 Incompetent to Stand Trial (IST)

Macon Gets New Mental Health Court

Yvonne Sherrill Receives the Department of Human Resources Forensic Services’ 1st Annual Debra Blum Award

Women at Risk: Neonaticide, Infanticide and Filicide

Clarifying the Process for Defendants Found Guilty but Mentally Ill or Guilty but Mentally Retarded

Judge Winston P. Bethel Wins Debra J Blum Award

Aspergers' Syndrome - The Odd, Eccentric, Socially Impaired Have Help

Kenneth Shepherd Gets His
Day in Court

Shock Therapy: It's Not a
Thing of the Past

Psychiatric Medications 101 has been updated.

A Victory for Competency in Simms Case

The Governor's Pilot Mental Health Diversion Program: The HELP Program, A Hall County Inititative

Dealing with a Schizophrenic Client

The Standard of Review for Competency Challenged

Honoring Debbie Blum, a Mental Health Pioneer